1958 Cleveland Indians
Franchise seasons · 1950s seasons
Independent, unofficial historical lineup simulator. Games here are simulated exhibitions, not historical results.
Compare historical seasons
Cleveland Indians franchise archive · Available years: 1903–2021 · 119 seasons.
These historical season records are separate from simulated exhibitions. — means the season record is unavailable. Year ranges describe this archive's coverage; team names reflect each season's historical name.
Same team, nearby years
| Season | Record (W–L) | Batting rows | Pitching rows |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1960 Cleveland Indians | 76–78 | 26 | 18 |
| 1959 Cleveland Indians | — | 25 | 16 |
| 1958 Cleveland Indians · Current season | — | 25 | 20 |
| 1957 Cleveland Indians | — | 22 | 16 |
| 1956 Cleveland Indians | — | 23 | 12 |
Same era: other teams in 1958
- 1958 Baltimore Orioles · 74–79
- 1958 Boston Red Sox · 79–75
- 1958 Chicago Cubs · 72–82
- 1958 Chicago White Sox · —
- 1958 Detroit Tigers · 77–77
- 1958 Kansas City Athletics · 73–81
More teams from 1958
- 1958 Los Angeles Dodgers · 71–83
- 1958 Milwaukee Braves · 92–62
- 1958 New York Yankees · 92–62
- 1958 Philadelphia Phillies · —
- 1958 Pittsburgh Pirates · —
- 1958 San Francisco Giants · 80–74
- 1958 St. Louis Cardinals · 72–82
- 1958 Washington Senators · 61–93
Roster and season statistics
Only players appear here. Staff are excluded from lineup choices. — means a statistic is unavailable. A roster player may have no batting or pitching row if they did not appear in those tables.
| Player | Position group | No. | Stat rows | AB | H | HR | AVG | IP | ERA | Rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gary Bell | Pitchers | 39 | pitching | — | — | — | — | 182.00 | 3.31 | Average (55) — 23 of 138 pitchers in the available 1958 rostersAn earned-run average of 3.31 over 182.00 innings informs this pitching score. Lower earned-run averages indicate better run prevention. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league. |
| Dick Brodowski | Pitchers | 48 | pitching | — | — | — | — | — | 0.00 | Not enough dataThe available innings and earned-run average do not support a reliable comparison. You can still select this pitcher; the exhibition uses estimated performance. |
| Chuck Churn | Pitchers | 32 | pitching | — | — | — | — | — | 6.23 | Not enough dataThe available innings and earned-run average do not support a reliable comparison. You can still select this pitcher; the exhibition uses estimated performance. |
| Jim Constable | Pitchers | 37 | pitching | — | — | — | — | 9.33 | 11.57 | Not enough dataThe available innings and earned-run average do not support a reliable comparison. You can still select this pitcher; the exhibition uses estimated performance. |
| Don Ferrarese | Pitchers | 34 | pitching | — | — | — | — | 94.67 | 3.71 | Average (52) — 54 of 138 pitchers in the available 1958 rostersAn earned-run average of 3.71 over 94.67 innings informs this pitching score. Lower earned-run averages indicate better run prevention. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league. |
| Mike Garcia | Pitchers | 25 | No stat row | — | — | — | — | — | — | No ratingThe source has no pitching stat row for this player. You can still select this pitcher; the exhibition uses estimated performance. |
| Mudcat Grant | Pitchers | 33 | pitching | — | — | — | — | 204.00 | 3.84 | Average (52) — 54 of 138 pitchers in the available 1958 rostersAn earned-run average of 3.84 over 204.00 innings informs this pitching score. Lower earned-run averages indicate better run prevention. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league. |
| Bob Kelly | Pitchers | 37 | pitching | — | — | — | — | 27.67 | 5.20 | Average (48) — 92 of 138 pitchers in the available 1958 rostersAn earned-run average of 5.20 over 27.67 innings informs this pitching score. Lower earned-run averages indicate better run prevention. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league. |
| Bob Lemon | Pitchers | 21 | pitching | — | — | — | — | — | 5.33 | Not enough dataThe available innings and earned-run average do not support a reliable comparison. You can still select this pitcher; the exhibition uses estimated performance. |
| Morrie Martin | Pitchers | 32 | pitching | — | — | — | — | — | 2.41 | Not enough dataThe available innings and earned-run average do not support a reliable comparison. You can still select this pitcher; the exhibition uses estimated performance. |
| Cal McLish | Pitchers | 22 | pitching | — | — | — | — | 225.67 | 2.99 | Average (58) — 10 of 138 pitchers in the available 1958 rostersAn earned-run average of 2.99 over 225.67 innings informs this pitching score. Lower earned-run averages indicate better run prevention. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league. |
| Don Mossi | Pitchers | 12 | pitching | — | — | — | — | — | 3.90 | Not enough dataThe available innings and earned-run average do not support a reliable comparison. You can still select this pitcher; the exhibition uses estimated performance. |
| Ray Narleski | Pitchers | 20 | pitching | — | — | — | — | 183.33 | 4.07 | Average (50) — 76 of 138 pitchers in the available 1958 rostersAn earned-run average of 4.07 over 183.33 innings informs this pitching score. Lower earned-run averages indicate better run prevention. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league. |
| Steve Ridzik | Pitchers | 35 | pitching | — | — | — | — | — | 2.08 | Not enough dataThe available innings and earned-run average do not support a reliable comparison. You can still select this pitcher; the exhibition uses estimated performance. |
| Herb Score | Pitchers | 27 | pitching | — | — | — | — | 41.00 | 3.95 | Average (51) — 62 of 138 pitchers in the available 1958 rostersAn earned-run average of 3.95 over 41.00 innings informs this pitching score. Lower earned-run averages indicate better run prevention. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league. |
| Dick Tomanek | Pitchers | 29 | pitching | — | — | — | — | 57.67 | 5.62 | Below average (44) — 123 of 138 pitchers in the available 1958 rostersAn earned-run average of 5.62 over 57.67 innings informs this pitching score. Lower earned-run averages indicate better run prevention. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league. |
| Hoyt Wilhelm | Pitchers | 26 | pitching | — | — | — | — | — | 2.49 | Not enough dataThe available innings and earned-run average do not support a reliable comparison. You can still select this pitcher; the exhibition uses estimated performance. |
| Hal Woodeshick | Pitchers | 28 | pitching | — | — | — | — | 71.67 | 3.64 | Average (52) — 54 of 138 pitchers in the available 1958 rostersAn earned-run average of 3.64 over 71.67 innings informs this pitching score. Lower earned-run averages indicate better run prevention. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league. |
| Dick Brown | Catchers | 11 | batting | 173 | 41 | 7 | .237 | — | — | Average (49) — 137 of 242 batters in the available 1958 rostersBatting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 173 at-bats and 7 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league. |
| Russ Nixon | Catchers | 15 | batting | 376 | 113 | 9 | .301 | — | — | Average (57) — 34 of 242 batters in the available 1958 rostersBatting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 376 at-bats and 9 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league. |
| Jay Porter | Catchers | 4 | batting | 85 | 17 | 4 | .200 | — | — | Average (47) — 175 of 242 batters in the available 1958 rostersBatting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 85 at-bats and 4 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league. |
| Earl Averill, Jr. | Infielders | 2 | No stat row | — | — | — | — | — | — | No ratingThe source has no batting stat row for this player. You can still select this batter; the exhibition uses estimated performance. |
| Bobby Ávila | Infielders | 1 | batting | 375 | 95 | 5 | .253 | — | — | Average (49) — 137 of 242 batters in the available 1958 rostersBatting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 375 at-bats and 5 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league. |
| Chico Carrasquel | Infielders | 17 | batting | 156 | 40 | 9 | .225 | — | — | Average (52) — 78 of 242 batters in the available 1958 rostersBatting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 156 at-bats and 9 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league. |
| Billy Harrell | Infielders | 38 | batting | 229 | 50 | 7 | .218 | — | — | Average (46) — 191 of 242 batters in the available 1958 rostersBatting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 229 at-bats and 7 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league. |
| Fred Hatfield | Infielders | 7 | batting | 8 | 1 | 0 | .125 | — | — | Not enough dataThe available at-bats and hits do not support a reliable comparison. You can still select this batter; the exhibition uses estimated performance. |
| Billy Hunter | Infielders | 7 | batting | 190 | 37 | 0 | .195 | — | — | Below average (41) — 239 of 242 batters in the available 1958 rostersBatting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 190 at-bats and 0 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league. |
| Randy Jackson | Infielders | 2 | batting | 91 | 22 | 4 | .242 | — | — | Average (50) — 117 of 242 batters in the available 1958 rostersBatting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 91 at-bats and 4 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league. |
| Billy Moran | Infielders | 16 | batting | 257 | 58 | 1 | .226 | — | — | Average (45) — 208 of 242 batters in the available 1958 rostersBatting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 257 at-bats and 1 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league. |
| Vic Power | Infielders | 10 | No stat row | — | — | — | — | — | — | No ratingThe source has no batting stat row for this player. You can still select this batter; the exhibition uses estimated performance. |
| Larry Raines | Infielders | 16 | batting | 9 | 0 | 0 | .000 | — | — | Not enough dataThe available at-bats and hits do not support a reliable comparison. You can still select this batter; the exhibition uses estimated performance. |
| Mickey Vernon | Infielders | 8 | batting | 355 | 104 | 8 | .293 | — | — | Average (56) — 37 of 242 batters in the available 1958 rostersBatting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 355 at-bats and 8 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league. |
| Preston Ward | Infielders | 36 | batting | 148 | 50 | 4 | .338 | — | — | Average (59) — 26 of 242 batters in the available 1958 rostersBatting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 148 at-bats and 4 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league. |
| Vic Wertz | Infielders | 23 | batting | 43 | 12 | 3 | .279 | — | — | Not enough dataThe available at-bats and hits do not support a reliable comparison. You can still select this batter; the exhibition uses estimated performance. |
| Rocky Colavito | Outfielders | 6 | both | 489 | 148 | 41 | .303 | — | 0.00 | Strong (64) — 8 of 242 batters in the available 1958 rostersBatting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 489 at-bats and 41 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league. |
| Larry Doby | Outfielders | 14 | batting | 247 | 70 | 13 | .285 | — | — | Average (56) — 37 of 242 batters in the available 1958 rostersBatting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 247 at-bats and 13 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league. |
| Gary Geiger | Outfielders | 31 | both | 195 | 45 | 1 | .231 | — | 9.00 | Average (46) — 191 of 242 batters in the available 1958 rostersBatting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 195 at-bats and 1 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league. |
| Rod Graber | Outfielders | 29 | batting | 8 | 1 | 0 | .125 | — | — | Not enough dataThe available at-bats and hits do not support a reliable comparison. You can still select this batter; the exhibition uses estimated performance. |
| Carroll Hardy | Outfielders | 30 | batting | 49 | 10 | 1 | .204 | — | — | Not enough dataThe available at-bats and hits do not support a reliable comparison. You can still select this batter; the exhibition uses estimated performance. |
| Woodie Held | Outfielders | 3 | batting | 144 | 28 | 3 | .194 | — | — | Below average (43) — 229 of 242 batters in the available 1958 rostersBatting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 144 at-bats and 3 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league. |
| Roger Maris | Outfielders | 5 | batting | 182 | 41 | 9 | .225 | — | — | Average (48) — 158 of 242 batters in the available 1958 rostersBatting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 182 at-bats and 9 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league. |
| Minnie Miñoso | Outfielders | 9 | batting | 556 | 168 | 24 | .302 | — | — | Strong (60) — 20 of 242 batters in the available 1958 rostersBatting average and home runs per at-bat inform this hitting score, using 556 at-bats and 24 home runs from the source. Shorter playing records receive more cautious scores. This rank compares simulation ratings, with equal scores sharing a rank; it is not a ranking of every player in the league. |
| Hal Naragon | Outfielders | 18 | batting | 9 | 3 | 0 | .333 | — | — | Not enough dataThe available at-bats and hits do not support a reliable comparison. You can still select this batter; the exhibition uses estimated performance. |
Build a lineup
Exhibition rules use nine hitters, including a DH, and one pitcher. The numbered slots are the batting order. Pick each player once. Opponent: 1958 Baltimore Orioles. Players without a rating remain selectable with estimated performance.
Simulated exhibition
Choose a lineup to play an exhibition.
Batting lines
Game log for the selected game
Roster and statistics adapted from Wikipedia contributors, 1958 Cleveland Indians season. Retrieved 2026-09-30T12:47:52.284431+00:00. Source material is under CC BY-SA 4.0. We grouped roster entries, excluded staff, joined stats by Wikipedia page title, converted baseball innings notation to outs, and derived approximate ratings and simulated outcomes. No official affiliation.